Home   Voices of the seed   Biopiracy of Turkey’s purple carrot

Biopiracy of Turkey’s purple carrot

Biopiracy of Turkey’s purple carrot

Austin, Texas, 20 Feb (Edward Hammond*) — Agribusiness giant Monsanto is marketing a purple carrot originating in Turkey over which it claims plant variety rights.

Anthonina is a Monsanto offering in the growing market for richly coloured carrots – red, gold, white and, in this case, purple, a colour particularly associated by health-conscious consumers with anthocyanin “antioxidants”, the natural plant pigments believed to protect against heart disease.

Most people think of carrots as being orange. That is mainly the result of work by Dutch plant breeders who, in the 16th and 17th centuries, bred carrots in that colour in order to indulge their royalty, giving rise to the wide adoption of orange varieties as being the customary colour for carrots.

How did Monsanto subsidiary Seminis, then, go back to a purple carrot if plant breeders haven’t paid much attention to them in 300 years? A program of intense plant breeding? No. Genetic engineering? No.

To bring a purple carrot to market, Seminis went to a part of the world where coloured carrots never stopped being cultivated – in this case, southern Turkey – and purchased some farmers’ seed.

After a simple process of selection, the company called this carrot its own, and has obtained plant variety rights (PVR) over it in both the United States (US PVPA Certificate 200400327) and Europe (European Union CPVO Certificate 20050779).

The US plant variety protection certificate shows how little innovation is necessary to appropriate somebody else’s seed under PVR laws.

The certificate reads: “During November 1999, a former Seminis representative, Mr. John Wester, purchased seeds of a landrace [farmer's variety], open-pollinated carrot variety at a farmers’ market in Adana, Turkey. He then sent this seed to the Seminis carrot breeder… The seed container … did not have a name on the package, so it was named ‘Turkey Black Carrot’…”

Then, as if embarrassed by its own claim, the company justified shopping for its intellectual property at farmers’ markets, describing the seed collection thus: “It is worth noting that this type of collection activity is similar to the ongoing activities of the USDA and any other seed collection conservatory where wild sources of germplasm are collected from remote isolated areas, as they can provide all kinds of new and exciting diversity.”

All kinds of new and exciting diversity, but in the Seminis case, it is not for conservation, but for intellectual property claims and profits.

(In the interest of accuracy, Seminis is not correct to suggest that Adana, a city with more than 1.5 million inhabitants at the centre of an agricultural heartland, is a “remote isolated area”.)

The process to turn the so-called “Turkey Black Carrot” farmers’ variety into Anthonina, intellectual property of Seminis, was not at all complicated.

Turkey Black Carrot was not bred with any other variety. Seminis simply planted the Turkish seeds and quickly selected the best carrots that cropped up for their purpose – mainly, plants that were slow to bolt and which had a desirable root shape and shade of purple colour.

The straightforward selection of Anthonina out of Turkey Black Carrot was completed over six generations grown in California between late 2000 and early 2004.

Seminis then applied for and received PVR in the United States and, later, Europe.

What more is known about the background of “Turkey Black Carrot”?

Seminis notes: “Mr. Wester left the employment of Seminis several years ago and it is unfortunate that we do not know where he is currently located.”

Apparently, Seminis would give Mr. Wester credit, but not the farmers who created the seed he collected.

Defenders of PVR would likely say that nothing is amiss with Monsanto’s appropriation of Anthonina, arguing that Turkish farmers can still plant “Turkey Black Carrot”.

No harm done? Not so. While it’s true that Turkish farmers can still plant their own carrots, that’s not the point.

The argument skirts critical issues:

First, Seminis did very little to make the carrot its own. Anthonina is essentially the same carrot that Turkish farmers created, especially with respect to the carrot’s most marketable feature – its colour. Monsanto owns PVR to what is fundamentally something it did not create.

Secondly, benefit-sharing appears to be completely absent. Having accessed, and continuing to utilise Turkish genetic resources (Turkey ratified the Convention on Biological Diversity in 1997, two years before the carrot seeds were sent to the US), Monsanto’s use of Turkish purple carrot leads to no benefit for the farmers who created it.

In this unusual case, the key details of the origin of the seed were disclosed, documenting the underwhelming process by which Monsanto came to own the innovation of others.

More typically, however, plant variety rights’ applicants are less forthcoming, or are not asked to even disclose where they obtained their source seeds, an unacceptable fault in plant variety protection laws that leads to the theft of farmers’ resources and innovation.

[* Edward Hammond is Director of Prickly Research (www.pricklyresearch.com) and has worked on biodiversity issues since 1994.]


Join Seed Freedom online:

Website – http://seedfreedom.in
Twitter – https://twitter.com/occupytheseed
Facebook – https://www.facebook.com/savetheseed
YouTube – http://www.youtube.com/user/occupytheseed
Sign the Declaration on Seed Freedom: http://seedfreedom.in/declaration/


  1. Pingback: SEO Firm

  2. Pingback: nike free damen 5.0

  3. Pingback: trash removal roswell ga

  4. Pingback: G-SHOCK 時計

  5. Pingback: 高級腕時計

  6. Pingback: 腕時計 レディース

  7. Pingback: ポーター 店舗

  8. Pingback: 腕時計 通販

  9. Pingback: ポーター 店舗

  10. Pingback: G-SHOCK 時計

  11. Pingback: アルマーニ 腕時計

  12. Pingback: G-SHOCK 時計

  13. Pingback: gucci belts for cheap

  14. Pingback: タイメックス 腕時計

  15. Pingback: コーチ 腕時計

  16. Pingback: ダコタバッグ

  17. Pingback: ハミルトン 時計

  18. Pingback: ダコタ アウトレット

  19. Pingback: プラダメンズ

  20. Pingback: ダコタ 長財布

  21. Pingback: プラダ アウトレット

  22. Pingback: ダコタ財布

  23. Pingback: プラダメンズ

  24. Pingback: トリーバーチ 財布

  25. Pingback: トリーバーチ ブーツ

  26. Pingback: tumi カバン

  27. Pingback: シャネル ピアス

  28. Pingback: シャネルネックレス

  29. Pingback: シャネル バッグ

  30. Pingback: コーチ アウトレット

  31. Pingback: TUMI 3way

  32. Pingback: トリーバーチ クラッチ

  33. Pingback: トリバーチ バッグ

  34. Pingback: TUMI 修理

  35. Pingback: nanoo

  36. Pingback: Trackback

  37. Pingback: deer antler spray for weight loss

  38. Pingback: how to get rid of cellulite

  39. Pingback: pixelitas.com

  40. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  41. Pingback: Hermes belt

  42. Pingback: sitemagazine.eu

  43. Pingback: wow gold online

  44. Pingback: wholesale oakley sunglasses

  45. Pingback: ダコタバッグ

  46. Pingback: クロエ バッグ ショルダー

  47. Pingback: http://www.getforeverrecovery.com/

  48. Pingback: wow gold

  49. Pingback: portefeuille longchamp

  50. Pingback: gamma blue 11s

  51. Pingback: creator a forever recovery

  52. Pingback: chaussures christian louboutin femme

  53. Pingback: nike tn requin pas cher

  54. Pingback: nike air max pas cher

  55. Pingback: oakley femme pas cher

  56. Pingback: nike pas cher

  57. Pingback: labor lawyer los angeles

  58. Pingback: replica Hermes bags

  59. Pingback: getforeverrecovery.com/

  60. Pingback: http://getforeverrecovery.com

  61. Pingback: federal employment lawyer

  62. Pingback: home security installation company in london

  63. Pingback: intruder alarm maintenance

  64. Pingback: air jordan 11 low

  65. Pingback: http://www.getforeverrecovery.com/

  66. Pingback: home security company in london

  67. Pingback: real air jordan 11 for sale

  68. Pingback: air jordan 5 retro oreo

  69. Pingback: gamma blue 11

  70. Pingback: air jordan 10 powder blue footlocker

  71. Pingback: nike air jordan 4 retro

  72. Pingback: Austin TX SEO

  73. Pingback: jordan shoes wallpapers

  74. Pingback: signs of drug addiction, and resources for ...

  75. Pingback: air jordan 14

  76. Pingback: air jordan 5 oreo

  77. Pingback: air jordan 11 low gs

  78. Pingback: air jordan 10 powder blue footlocker

  79. Pingback: cheap ray ban sunglasses

  80. Pingback: air jordans for kids

  81. Pingback: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-58o9E507M8

  82. Pingback: cheap toms men

  83. Pingback: nike tn requin

  84. Pingback: nike pas cher

  85. Pingback: cheap fake oakleys

  86. Pingback: nike air max pas cher

  87. Pingback: LED signs

  88. Pingback: SEO Minneapolis Tips

  89. Pingback: home security installation company

  90. Pingback: http://www.getforeverrecovery.com

  91. Pingback: credit monitoring

  92. Pingback: get forever recovery

  93. Pingback: Dallas Custom Commercial Signs

  94. Pingback: cheap mbt

  95. Pingback: camaro c.o.p.o.

  96. Pingback: Cerame Kia

  97. Pingback: christian louboutin soldes

  98. Pingback: nike free run pas cher

  99. Pingback: MBT Scarpe Outlet

  100. Pingback: www.getforeverrecovery.com/

  101. Pingback: saint francois longchamp

  102. Pingback: garcinia cambogia dr oz video

  103. Pingback: garcinia combogia

  104. Pingback: longchamp Sac en bandoulière en cuir Occasion - Très bon état

  105. Pingback: click here for more

  106. Pingback: muchas noticias

  107. Pingback: Soccer IQ

  108. Pingback: 5 star hotels in tokyo

  109. Pingback: Giuseppe Zanotti London Suede Zip Sneakers Low-Top Sneakers

  110. Pingback: Strategic Campaigns Inc Kansas City Missouri

  111. Pingback: Trackback

  112. Pingback: accommodation durban

  113. Pingback: new balance femme pas cher

  114. Pingback: Giuseppe Zanotti London Sneakers High-Top Sneakers Femme Light Brown

  115. Pingback: Giuseppe Zanotti London Velet Red Metalic Sneakers Femme High-Top Sneakers

  116. Pingback: Giuseppe Zanotti London Suede Sneakers Femme

  117. Pingback: Giuseppe Zanotti Metallic London Sneakers High-Top Sneakers Homme

  118. Pingback: click this link

  119. Pingback: pure garcinia cambogia extract at gnc

  120. Pingback: garcinia cambogia and cleanse

  121. Pingback: pure cambogia garcinia dr oz

  122. Pingback: new balance 574

  123. Pingback: Home

  124. Antonina, yada Anadolu’da pek yakın zamana kadar kara havuç diye bilinen, pazarlarında binlerce yıldır satılıp alınan, mor renkli, bildiğiniz kara havuç artık bir şirketin lisanslı entellektüel varlığına çevrilivermiş. hem de hiç fazla sıkıntı çekilmeden..Hani en ufak bir tuvalet ekleme için başvurursunda senden ÇED istemedikleri kalır, burada öyle bir sıkıntı yok. ”Kara havuç benimdir de, senin olsun abim!” Bu nasıl bi şey, ben anlayamadım.

  125. Pingback: ถ่ายรูป

  126. Pingback: garcinia cambogia extract gnc side effects

  127. Pingback: african mask facts

  128. Pingback: Nike Air Max 90 Essential Chaussure pour Femme

  129. Pingback: credit report gov

  130. Pingback: my private page

  131. Pingback: Visit Website

  132. Pingback: kosiarka ręczna

  133. Pingback: personal loans for people with bad credit

  134. Pingback: Trackback

  135. Pingback: Trackback

  136. Its pity to note that PVP and farmers rights are still being violated. Its a Wake up call for turkey regulators. At least Monanto should have thought of “Benefit Sharing” formula along with its commercialization plans.

  137. Farmers are always owner of the seeds .They own it for generation hundreds of thousands of years all of a sudden a corporate get seeds from farmer do some modification and claim ownership right or patent right is not acceptable